Friday, April 28, 2006

Pure Sabacc

Today I gave my Threnody analysis presentation to Dr. Lillios in my final lesson. I pretty much did nothing but work on it since Wednesday.

This whole week up until now was completely bleak. I’m talking harrowing. I have been faced with not only the overwhelming amount of work required to prepare two major projects in one week, but also the prospect of the faculty not allowing me to pass one or both of them. I had to consider the possibility that maybe I simply wasn’t going to be allowed to leave this place. Not because of my own shortcomings, but because of the unfair judgement of the faculty here.

But they all underestimated me.

I’m set. Lillios likes my presentation, and she is proud of me for how I’ve been shaped into an academic. Those are not my words. I find them sickening and laughable at the same time. I haven’t been shaped into anything. Not by the faculty here. I’m playing them.

Because the only time I speak in seminar is to question something they feel is unquestionable, they take me for an unprofessional fool. Just because I don’t worship their ideals for “high art,” I am clearly not cut out for a Master of Music in Composition degree.

Except that I did an astonishing amount of work this week, and I did it astonishingly well. Why is that astonishing? I don’t know. It might be, if you don’t take into account my obsessive work ethic and firm grasp on the English language. Maybe… and I’m just going out on a limb here… I’m intellectually capable of great things?

Proofreading my notes, Lillios suggested I not use the word “sovereignty” in my description of this one imitative section. It makes perfect sense, and is very economic in communicating an idea. That’s the whole point of using any word. But she says it will sound like I got that paragraph from someone else.

I told her that this is what pisses me off about this whole process, and she concedes it pisses her off, too. They want you to be at a supreme level of academic rhetoric, but they don’t believe you when you do it. Behold the paradox of committee judgement.

The real challenge comes with the Q&A for both my analysis presentation and my thesis defense. It’s a lot of deflection and wordplay. We discussed this element when I met with Lillios on Tuesday. I said, “So it’s a dance.” Lillios said, “Yes, that’s exactly what it is.”

I finally just expressed my worries, “Honestly, I think your colleagues have a very low opinion of me, and are going to make it very hard for me to pass.”

The final nail in the coffin: Lillios didn’t deny it. She didn’t even look surprised or concerned. She didn’t even blink. She looked me right in the eyes and said, “Then you have to prove them wrong by showing them they're wrong.”

Don’t think too hard about the grammatical syntax of that sentence; it’s the stupidest advice I’ve ever received. It just confirmed by paranoia.

I’ll play their little game. I have an advantage: very few people are aware of how cool and diplomatic I can actually be.

I’ll play their little game. I have a strong hand to play, and everyone thinks I’m bluffing.

In the darkest hour, the tiniest spark of hope is a radiant flare.

Monday, April 24, 2006

All That Remains

It’s the last week of classes, then finals week. The New Music Ensemble concert was about two weeks ago, and it went over well, I guess. My tubist friend Amanda is excited about me reworking my cue into a piece for her (it was originally intended as such).

The gamelan final concert was Thursday, so now that’s over. I finished the draft of my final project in counterpoint. Although there is definitely a counterpoint assignment from about three weeks ago that I never did…

Dr. Engebretsen has jury duty tomorrow and Wednesday, so I’ll be teaching Wednesday instead of Friday this week. I have one more round of papers to grade, then all I have left to do for my assistanceship is grade sightsinging finals next week.

Tuesday, May 2 is when I’m giving my analysis presentation to the faculty. My beloved superiors, in all their prudence, have scheduled my thesis defense immediately after that. Two significant presentations, back-to-back. Until then, there are plenty of preparatory hoops to jump through.

It’s pretty much the worst possible thing they could throw at me at this point. I’m actually not at all surprised, either.

Didn’t I say it before? This is what I do.

It’s the culmination of my academic life. It’s all that stands between me and everything I should have been doing all along. Composing, for example. Learning orchestration. I don’t know, maybe even playing my primary instrument for a change.

Now I can clearly see every obstacle before me. All that remains will be taken care of soon. Every day is a race, though. I can feel time running out… I just hope I can spend time with each of my friends one last time before it’s too late. Speaking of too late, I have to get Logic Pro 7 and Sibelius 4 while I still have my student discount.

I don’t think I’ll go to my commencement in August.

Tuesday, April 11, 2006

Maelstrom, Part II: Reckoning

I wrote my appeal letter, and turned in the materials to the committee. They met this morning, after which I sequestered Dr. Lillios. She told me the solution they came up with.

The new plan is that I will give my presentation again. Instead of starting over with another piece, however, I will keep with Threnody. I will have to do a complete overhaul, of course. I will also have to present during finals week, rather than over the summer. Call it a Pyrrhic victory? Wait, no, it’s still a travesty.

According to Dr. Lillios, the core of the problem is that Dr. Shrude is not convinced that I did not plagiarize. There have been many theoretical analyses on Threnody, and she thinks my words were not my own. But they were. She has given someone else trouble for that recently. She can’t consider the possibility that anyone can speak intelligently? Apparently my professional voice in incongruous with my conversational voice. No shit. Meanwhile, Dr. Lillios says my presentation had “too much meat.”

What all that means is that I did too good of a job, and nobody expected it. I’m a better writer than the faculty, and it cost me. I realize that now. That’s not arrogance talking. Yesterday I was shown some of the faculty’s writing. It’s true.

I did the analysis myself. If that is in question, then the problem is far deeper than I thought. See, I’m a simple, humble man. I have little pride, and I am unpretentious. All I really want is harmony. But don’t you ever challenge my integrity. That’s when I turn violent.

The whole point of this presentation is that each of the students does the analysis entirely on their own. It’s not my fault I did it so well they think I stole something.

Dr. Lillios was quick to point the finger at me for waiting too long to choose a piece to analyze. As I recall, I decided on Harmonielehre about two months prior to the presentations. She shot that down. Then, I finally decided on The Infernal Machine. That didn’t work, either. Threnody was my third attempt. I did not just sit on my hands all that time.

The other problem is that Dr. Lillios could not defend me well enough because even she couldn’t follow my presentation; my scope was not “narrow” enough. This is exactly the problem all of the grad students are having, and have been having all year: the faculty never communicate effectively. Never. They never really give us parameters on anything, proceed to assure us “it will be fine,” then fault us for not doing it right. It’s happened to everyone else I’ve talked to. Everyone. About everything.

The faculty believe themselves infallible. They have become all but ineffective in their role in society. This maelstrom has awakened the student body. While everything I’ve talked about is strikingly similar to other students’ grievances, my story is the highly-concentrated epitome. Something is happening… the rift between the faculty and the grad students has been ripped wide open. My experience has galvanized the others into a sort of mental insurrection. Thus, I have become a martyr. Faith in the establishment is toppling over like a drunken game of Jenga.

Grad school is 100% bullshit (from concentrate).

My fate is sealed: both my thesis defense and my analysis presentation will be during finals week. How fitting. The end comes not with a whimper, but with a bang. I have been cheated out of my entire semester. From here on out, I will not veil my contempt.

I have made my judgement, alongside many of my comrades: Bowling Green State University is beyond salvation.

Monday, April 10, 2006

Maelstrom, Part I: Immolation

I am writing to apprise you of the travesty of today—an outrage far surpassing any I have ever conceived of in the academic realm.

You are thinking, “Oh boy, another irate rant. This should be fun.” My friends, this transcends mere anger and frustration. This falls nowhere short of atrocity. I am so far beyond anger, it doesn’t even register on the emotional spectrum. I am not in any danger of having some petty temper tantrum over it; I am completely detached from such feelings. I can’t even describe what it is I’m feeling, because it’s almost incomprehensible.

Let me tell you of this outrage.

This morning I met with Dr. Lillios. We covered two things that made this the worst day of my two years here.

First, in a nutshell, my thesis defense is officially pushed back to finals week. I don’t have to reiterate the details behind the thesis saga, so I won’t review any old news. But I was scheduled to defend this Wednesday. I worked all weekend preparing an airtight defense presentation for my committee. Now, I have to wait. I was repeatedly misinformed about certain things. Now I have to take care of those things before I can present my defense. However, Dr. Shrude is going to Russia for a while, so the soonest I can defend is finals week. I’ll let you imagine my feelings on this matter.

After discussing that at great length, Dr. Lillios told me about this next part. This is far worse than the thesis screw-over—I know, hard to believe, isn’t it?

Dr. Lillios was not present for my presentation, but she said the other three faculty members met and unanimously agreed that… my presentation “was not passable.”

Side note: until this year, all of these presentations were recognized as little more than a rite of passage; all presentations were basically pass-pass, not pass-fail.

The reason for this is that I apparently left out salient information on my handouts. That is, the timbral timeline (a line graph) and my bibliography. [See earlier post, The Beacons Are Lit].

Let me explain what this means if they don’t pass my presentation. Aside from the obvious humiliation, this is going to cost me a lot of trouble. I would have to do a completely new presentation on a complete different piece, and I would have to present it to the faculty “sometime over the summer.”

If that happens—and it probably will—then I will literally have done twice the work everyone else has. My thesis is double the requirement, and I will have to do a second analysis presentation. That, my friends, is a travesty.

Dr. Lillios is going to watch the tape of my presentation tonight and meet with the others tomorrow morning. I pray she can talk some sense into them and get them to do the right thing. There are some things they should consider:

First of all, I was unaware the bibliography was required. The whole point was that we analyze the piece ourselves.

Second, since I was the first to present, I think I deserve a little slack; my only frame of reference was the group from last year, which wasn’t really that high-caliber to begin with.

Third, the missing chart really didn’t disrupt my presentation. It was little more than academic eye-candy, to show that I did a lot of work and put a lot of thought into it. The chart was backing up a point I was making that really wasn’t part of the main focus of my presentation anyway. It didn’t really weaken my case; in fact, I would have barely discussed had I put it in there.

A part of me believes that once they see that, I should be granted justice. Given the fact that my analysis was solid (more so than most of my peers’ so far), I would expect a little bit more credit than utter failure. Even my peers are outraged for me. Everyone I’ve talked to is downright shocked by the faculty’s decision. Several of them are disgusted at how much trouble the faculty have been giving me this semester. So it’s not my paranoia, it’s not me whining about things not going my way. No, people who aren’t even affected by this are outraged on principle.

I think the main reason I’ve been denied is that there’s a shadow of a doubt. Once they see that the oversight did not actually detract from the substance of my analysis, I should be exonerated.

Apparently substance means nothing to the faculty here. Given the kind of “music” they write, that seems to be an adequate synopsis. I’ve lost all faith in this program. I’ve lost all respect for the faculty now, too. And no one can blame me. What I said about hoping to get out of here without thinking it was a total waste of my time—forget it. It’s too late for that. What I said about getting out of here without being bitter—too late. Now I just have to get out of here.

All this makes me appreciate Dr. Gooch (from Truman) all the more.

This inequity will not stand. If, after tomorrow, they still won’t pass me, then I will take the fight to their doorstep. First, I will individually appeal to each of them. If that still won’t sway them, I will take it up with the dean. Yes. I will go over their heads, because I will be justified in doing so. If I have to, I’ll even get my peers to sign a petition on my behalf.

Consider this: if one of these professors ever screws up an overhead projection or a handout, by the same reasoning they should lose tenure. That’s harsh, isn’t it?

Herr Vogler was right: I’m becoming a martyr.

Friday, April 07, 2006

Molossus

This week in review: a bunch of crap. There are two things that vaguely resemble accomplishments... therefore making me feel closer to the end.

Gamelan took a trip yesterday to Otterbein College... which is in some town near Columbus. Pretty much as soon as Counterpoint II was out at 11:20, my day was shot. Loading the U-Haul truck... going there... unloading and setting up... giving a demonstration... going to dinner... doing the concert... loading up... going back to BG... unloading again. Otterbein provided us with a kickin' dinner, but other than that I did not enjoy the experience. I rode in the truck with Dr. Harnish, while four (or was it five) other cars of people went separately. This was by my own volition; I did not want to be stuck in a carful of people who annoy me, so I went with Harnish.

When at last I got back to my beloved car, it was 11:20 PM. At this point, I was dying for two things: my own music to listen to and a burger. Dude, it's hard not to listen to music for a whole day. So finally I felt like I was back in charge of my life, and I put in Batman Begins and took a quick night drive to Burger King with the windows down. Man, that felt good.

Two more weeks until the final gamelan concert. I can't wait to be done. The novelty wore off after the first concert. I'm still glad to be in it, but... man. I went through a lot of Excedrin this semester.

The second thing about this week is that I recorded about 13 minutes (4 separate cues) of original music for Starbuck's poetry reading project. There was a fifth cue for which I simply remixed an older composition of mine, so I'm not counting that.

The music is quasi-improvisatory, for solo piano (me). I tied the pieces together so there is some cohesion. One cue was just me tooling around like George Crumb, occasionally quoting clusters from another cue. My favorite of the cues clocks in at 5:25, and is structured around four "cells" of ideas. It is carefully structured, but there is room for some improvisation. It's actually the kind of stuff they put on Praecepta concerts here... or Student Composers' Forums. Mind you, that doesn't say much. But it's the best one of the four.

This summer, I plan on making a piece for extended-technique piano. It will be at least 16 minutes, but it will not be improvisatory at all. This is one of about 14 worthwhile ideas I have in mind for the summer... we'll see which pieces I actually get around to writing.

Monday, April 03, 2006

The Beacons Are Lit

Tonight was the night of my analysis presentation and Tammy's choral conducting recital. My presentation went unbelievably awry. In my fervor of stapling together handouts and scores to Threnody, I mistakenly left out the timbral timeline page, which was included in my earlier draft. A mountain of tiny things went wrong on top of that, and there were a couple of dickish questions posed to me at the end. It was one of the most disappointing experiences of this entire semester. I did say beforehand, even the worst-case scenario couldn't sink me (this project was mostly bullshit to begin with), and I hold to that statement. Still, it does make me feel extraordinarily bad. Later, someone told me he thought my presentation was still the best of the four tonight. Whether or not that's how the faculty see it, one thing remains true: it's done. Time to move on.

I left the presentations early to meet the choir rehearsal at the local church, where the concert was.

My piece, Returning, went well. I got a lot of compliments (in some cases, even adulation), which didn't flatter me at all for some reason. I mean, I was glad to see that the audience was affected in the way I intended, but I was pretty detached after a long, melancholy day. Fortunately, the naysayers whom I expected wouldn't like the piece didn't even show up. This was planned on my part. By waiting to give the composition studio short notice about the concert, it did not become a required event by default; people only attended out of sincere interest, not obligation.

The performers were all brilliant. Assuming the church's recording technology didn't screw it up, it should make for an excellent recording.

Dr. Lillios spent the weekend in Chicago, but her flight was laid over in St. Charles (small world, huh Jon?). She missed both events. I will suffer no more indignities at the hands of the faculty at this masturbatorium. If she gives me crap about my blunder (it was videotaped), I am going to let her know quite well that I have a high awareness of every nuance of an academic presentation. I will not let my committee make my thesis defense next week rough just because of tonight.

This week I will have to prepare that presentation... the end draws near.